I'm glad other people saw that! I was say he, Jacob, is the one up there that hasn't seemed to grown at all, just gone backwards.

The thing I like about stefano is he listens to what they say and atleast uses the information to fight back. Although I have to say last night I was thinking he looks better when he sings with his eyes closed .... his one eye was weird looking!

I agree, Jacob hasn't grown any as an artist during the process. To me, he has remained the same. I know a lot of people that are voting for him just because he is gay, but not me.

I like Scotty lol.

Scotty and Jacob. If I close my eyes and just listen, it's their voices alone that stand out.

That's my litmus test and I'm sticking to it.

Words

Well, Scotty makes my skin crawl. I had to turn the volume down. Same thing, over and over just with more facial convulsions. aack

James.....while I think he can sing, he didn't SING last night he yelled. (sorry that's what I think of heavy metal...yelling). blech

Paul..Paul...Paul...go home please. My amusement with you has worn thin. I thought you demolished that song last night.

I never really liked Jacob that much. It's like he's holding back or something...I dunno, something missing there.

I'm positive I will NOT like who America (the kids) voted off tonight.

And seriously, I still meant what I said earlier. They all have talent. Some just are starting to wear thin on me LOL

My bottom 3
 

Based on what i saw last night my bottom three would be Paul, Haley and Casey.

As I have said, Paul has outstayed his welcome, Haley was weak last night and my fear is Casey should have done in the Air Tonight instead of the song he picked. The public is finicky and if the audience voting doesn't know the song they are singing, this makes me nervous.

All the time Casey is singing the song i'm talking to the TV, bad choice, bad choice, you just sealed your fate.

As everyone said last night to Stefano, you have to sing to win not to stay. It's great to have integrity and be true to one self but this is a competition and you have to play to win, not be able to lay your head on your pillow and say you stuck to your guns and sang the song YOU wanted to sing.

Is the first Casey suppose to be paul?

LMAO! I thought J had a crush on him as well. Too funny.

To be honest, usually at this point in American Idol, I would have 2-3 favorites that I would want to win. I can't really say that I have a favorite this year. Well, if I HAD to pick ONE, I would pick Scotty. Not sure why I don't have a few fav's. Maybe Idol seems a little more staged this season than it has on prior seasons???

Addios Paul!

Ok....I just saw what Gemmie meant about Scotty holding the microphone. What's up with that? :blink: A agree it's annoying.


And I agree with everything Moonie just said.

Of all the people getting on my nerves, Ryan tops the list.

I'm really pleased with the outcome tonight. As the weeks go by, I still can't decide on a favorite. Haley, at her best, is one favorite. But, at her worst, she should go home. Same with Jacob. I can't help loving Scotty, even though country is not my favorite genre.

Just a reminder..........


Please be careful what you say during or just after the show. We don't want to give too much away and spoil it for the people on the west coast who don't see the show til later in the evening. :thumbsup:

ABSOLUTELY!!!!

Finally America got it right !

Next, Jacob .... I agree he has not grown.

And KUDOS to Hailey N Casey last night .... They could record that now in my opinion.

Kelly looked good last nite... and sounded great. Good for you Kelly !

Just trying to figure out when it's over .. what will I watch then ..... ?