Quote:
Originally Posted by Linus
[Posting as a member]
I'm not sure where an association of claiming an identity automatically means that you're against something.
|
It does not. Of course. Defending or reclaiming one might be taking a position against another. It often is the case. i have given examples.
Let's look at this quote -- from Kobi, whom i did not mean to offend by not using her name.
Quote:
I am a freakin lesbian - one of those relic women who wants to be with women who want to be with other women.
I am tired of feeling invisible in my own community. I am tired of feeling like a guest in my own community.
|
Who MIGHT be making her feel like a guest in her OWN community? Perhaps someone NOT a "woman who wants to be with other women?" i am guessing. The possibilities of people who choose to ID as lesbian but are not women loving women are somewhat limited. i speculated.
There's a ton of research on identity formation, much of which talks about how it is created by defining oneself in opposition to the other, by disavowing another group. i think that's a normal way of thinking. But ID formation on a greater than individual level is sticky stuff. i used to be offended (as a woman) by definitions of femme that implied that a reconsidered and reconstructed femme femininity was somehow superior to that of straight women. Anyway, femme cultural products are full of such statements. Less so anymore.
My point is that ID formation can come out of disavowals of the other. It can disparage the other. Definitions that imply that straight women are less reflective of or transgressive in their femininity are examples.
But when you take it up a level to DEFENDING a supposedly beleaguered identity, you enter into a discourse that does more than potentially demean the other. The poor me stuff can lead to justifications for exclusion or worse. It's the rhetoric of oppression. The speakers may SOUND like victims, but they are justifying something else.
So i am not calling anyone here an oppressor. But this kind of discourse is dangerous. In any context.