American Idol Fan Club

[Gemme]

Originally Posted by Arwen

Why do I cry at the darned auditions. I really like Steven Tyler as a judge. He's very generous.

Last girl of Nashville? Final four prediction.

I. Loved. Her.



The 15 year olds have BROUGHT IT this season! I'm really excited to see them progress, though I suspect many of them will be eaten up by the show and the stress.

Steven is a naughty puppy and it really irritated me in the first episode when he and Randy did a high five while Jennifer hugged the booty girl with the silver stars on her boobs. But I do find his criticisms to be honest and kind. That was unexpected for me.

I figured Jennifer would go the mama route, since her twins are toddlers now and it's pretty hard to shut that nurturing instinct off, and she did. She's been pretty upfront...after the first few times she had to say no...that is.

Randy's been more forthright than in previous seasons. I don't think he's mean. I think he's just tired of it all. 10 years he's been listening to people yammer on about how this is their dream and how good they are and they sound like that Younique girl in the blue prom dress.