American Idol Fan Club

musicman · 04-14-2011, 04:12 PM

Based on what i saw last night my bottom three would be Paul, Haley and Casey.

As I have said, Paul has outstayed his welcome, Haley was weak last night and my fear is Casey should have done in the Air Tonight instead of the song he picked. The public is finicky and if the audience voting doesn't know the song they are singing, this makes me nervous.

All the time Casey is singing the song i'm talking to the TV, bad choice, bad choice, you just sealed your fate.

As everyone said last night to Stefano, you have to sing to win not to stay. It's great to have integrity and be true to one self but this is a competition and you have to play to win, not be able to lay your head on your pillow and say you stuck to your guns and sang the song YOU wanted to sing.

Strappie · 04-14-2011, 04:36 PM

Scotty .... While I like him as a country singer. I didn't like him last night... He will be in the top 3 (my prediction)

Paul... While I like his super unique style (he will get signed on with someone) because he is so unique ... I'm ready for him to go...

Stefano.... GOOOOOOOOOOOOO HOME already!!!

Jacob .... I like him singing gospel, he also will be signed by someone. He can go anytime too..

Casey... As for him... I truly love this kid.. talk about taking chances and risking everything by playing a stand up base and not changing himself. I like him.. I do hope he makes it to at least the top 4.

I'm getting a little concerned about Lauren, I didn't think she had such a great week.. I think it was safe. I want to hear her bust those pipes out, like she did when she sang to Steven

I hate to admit, Haley's voice is super sexy. But if she isn't singing raspy it's not that great. So if she left I wouldn't feel bad.

The Oopster · 04-14-2011, 04:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Strappie

Scotty .... While I like him as a country singer. I didn't like him last night... He will be in the top 3 (my prediction)

Casey... While I like his super unique style (he will get signed on with someone) because he is so unique ... I'm ready for him to go...

Stefano.... GOOOOOOOOOOOOO HOME already!!!

Jacob .... I like him singing gospel, he also will be signed by someone. He can go anytime too..

Casey... As for him... I truly love this kid.. talk about taking chances and risking everything by playing a stand up base and not changing himself. I like him.. I do hope he makes it to at least the top 4.

I'm getting a little concerned about Lauren, I didn't think she had such a great week.. I think it was safe. I want to hear her bust those pipes out, like she did when she sang to Steven

I hate to admit, Haley's voice is super sexy. But if she isn't singing raspy it's not that great. So if she left I wouldn't feel bad.

Is the first Casey suppose to be paul?

04-14-2011, 04:12 PM	#1
musicman Member How Do You Identify?: NA Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: NA Posts: 209 My Photo Gallery Thanks: 195 Thanked 429 Times in 125 Posts Rep Power: 3610464	My bottom 3 Based on what i saw last night my bottom three would be Paul, Haley and Casey. As I have said, Paul has outstayed his welcome, Haley was weak last night and my fear is Casey should have done in the Air Tonight instead of the song he picked. The public is finicky and if the audience voting doesn't know the song they are singing, this makes me nervous. All the time Casey is singing the song i'm talking to the TV, bad choice, bad choice, you just sealed your fate. As everyone said last night to Stefano, you have to sing to win not to stay. It's great to have integrity and be true to one self but this is a competition and you have to play to win, not be able to lay your head on your pillow and say you stuck to your guns and sang the song YOU wanted to sing.

04-14-2011, 04:36 PM	#2
Strappie Senior Member How Do You Identify?: Butch Preferred Pronoun?: I know who I am... Doesn't matter Relationship Status: It's a new day.... Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: Mpls, MN Posts: 3,283 My Photo Gallery Thanks: 3,813 Thanked 4,945 Times in 1,350 Posts Rep Power: 21474856	Scotty .... While I like him as a country singer. I didn't like him last night... He will be in the top 3 (my prediction) Paul... While I like his super unique style (he will get signed on with someone) because he is so unique ... I'm ready for him to go... Stefano.... GOOOOOOOOOOOOO HOME already!!! Jacob .... I like him singing gospel, he also will be signed by someone. He can go anytime too.. Casey... As for him... I truly love this kid.. talk about taking chances and risking everything by playing a stand up base and not changing himself. I like him.. I do hope he makes it to at least the top 4. I'm getting a little concerned about Lauren, I didn't think she had such a great week.. I think it was safe. I want to hear her bust those pipes out, like she did when she sang to Steven I hate to admit, Haley's voice is super sexy. But if she isn't singing raspy it's not that great. So if she left I wouldn't feel bad.